CatholicTV is a 24/7 television network that broadcasts local and national religious programming and live events for the Catholic church in America.
Today is
The New York Times Case

Download the Fact Sheet on the New York Times case

 

As the Documents are Released,
Know This:
Media Coverage Since 1993
Has Been Extensive

Key Facts about the DocumentsMedia Articles Since 1993

 

The Connecticut Supreme Court has ordered the release of sealed documents relating to the so-called "New York Times Case."

Once the documents are released, we expect the secular media will publish them.

Unfortunately, we also expect the coverage to lack context, background, and the facts.

Media coverage of the case Rosado vs. Bridgeport Roman Catholic Diocesan Corp. et. al.
has been extensive throughout the State of Connecticut and beyond, from the filing of the 23 lawsuits in January 1993, to the March 8, 2001 settlement, and in the years since.

Contrary to what the media has claimed, this case has been widely covered, and the Diocese of Bridgeport has been open, honest, and transparent.

Key Facts About the Documents

Here is what you need to know about the documents that are being unsealed:

  • The documents substantiate the painful truth that was first revealed back in 1993 when 23 victims came forward and brought complaints against the Diocese. Many of them confirm the harm perpetrated against innocent children by trusted priests in the 1960s and 1970s — more than 30 years ago.

  • These documents contain pre trial materials relating to the 23 claims settled in 2001, including personnel records, deposition testimony, medical opinions and other internal Church memoranda.

  • All of these documents were provided by the Diocese as part of a pre-trial process where the standards of evidence are not as rigorous as those that govern evidence used at trial.

  • The documents relate to cases involving seven priests that have been widely covered by the media. Between 1993 and 2002, more than 200 media reports (below) were published about these and other cases including extensive
    Hartford Courant coverage in 2002 in an article that published (without permission) many of the sealed documents. The coverage included the names of the accused priests, critiques of the Diocese’s handling of the complaints, victims’ accounts and many other details.

  • All of the sealed documents were made available to the victims and their attorneys.

  • Bishop William Lori has held a number of press conferences on the subject of abuse of minors by clergy in the Bridgeport Diocese. During a press conference in April 2002, he disclosed the names of offending priests and confirmed that all credibly accused priests had been removed from ministry.

  • Of the seven priests associated with these cases, five were removed and banned from ministry, one was deceased at the time the allegation was brought forward, and the case against the seventh priest was unsubstantiated. He remains in ministry today.

  • This is old news. It does not reflect the true culture change has been effected across the Church regarding our knowledge of and ability to deal with sexual abuse. We have worked diligently and transparently to address the issue of clergy sexual abuse, and today we remain committed to reaching out to support those who have been harmed and doing everything in our power to provide Safe Environments for children.

Media Articles

Listed below is a selection of published articles from 1993-2003 relating to the case, arranged by the mention of one of the five priests included in the 2001 settlement, all of whom have been removed from ministry:

Also listed are articles relating to Father Joseph Malloy, who was included in the settlement but is innocent and in good standing.

Also listed are articles relating to Laurence Brett, a former priest with claims of sexual abuse that the Diocese has settled. Brett was removed from ministry and laicized.

Finally, there are listings of article relating to the two Bishops of Bridgeport during the period 1993 to the present:

Note

This article listing is not comprehensive. It contains only the articles which were received and retained over the years by the Office of Communications of the Diocese of Bridgeport.

One can safely assume that far more than the 220 articles listed here have been published.


 

General articles on the "Rosado" and "New York Times" cases

These articles mention all of the priests in question.

Headline Publication Date of Publication Page Summary
  Memorandum on Motion to Dismiss   Connecticut Law Tribune   12/12/1994       Diocese tries to get Rosado case dismissed  
Egan is Leaving "Unfinished Work" on Abuse, Victims Say Associated Press 6/16/2000 Egan heads to New York, Sharon See, John Fleetwood, and Brian Freibitt rehash cases, want resolution
  Diocese Announces the Resolution of Lawsuits   Fairfield County Catholic   Mar/Apr 2001   4   Msgr Bronkiewicz, administrator and chancellor of the Diocese, announced the successful conclusion of the mediation process. Page includes diocesan support for Father Joseph Malloy and a statement by Msgr. Bronkiewicz  
Diocese Admits to Priest Sexual Abuse Greenwich Time 3/9/2001 A1 6 priests abuse former parishioners - profiles of Pcolka, Carr, Federici, Coleman, Gorecki, Malloy, Brett
  Diocese Settles Sex Abuse Suit   Stamford Advocate   3/9/2001   A1   6 priests abuse former parishioners - No profiles of Pcolka, Carr, Federici, Coleman, Gorecki, Malloy, Brett  
Church Admits Priests Abuse Hartford
Courant
3/9/2001 A1 6 priests abuse former parishioners - profiles of Pcolka, Carr, Federici, Coleman, Gorecki, Malloy, Brett
  Diocese Settles Sex Case   New Haven Register   3/9/2001   A7   6 priests abuse former parishioners - profiles of Pcolka, Carr, Federici, Coleman, Gorecki, Malloy, Brett  
Diocese Settles Sex Abuse Claims Norwalk Hour 3/9/2001 A1 6 priests abuse former parishioners - profiles of Pcolka, Carr, Federici, Coleman, Gorecki, Malloy, Brett
  Priests Suits Settled   Connecticut Post   3/9/2001   A1   6 priests abuse former parishioners - profiles of Pcolka, Carr, Federici, Coleman, Gorecki, Malloy, Brett  
Diocese refuses to Oust Priests Connecticut Post 3/10/2001 A1 Priests under suspension with pay and a chronological timeline of the abuse
  Court Allows Sex Claims   Connecticut Post   1/29/2002   A1   Judge McWeeny allows introduction of claims against 7 other priests  
Diocese files Checked by Lori for Sexual Threats Connecticut Post 3/14/2002 A7 Disposition of Priests and Bishop Lori's apology
  Doctors: Church Used Us   Hartford
Courant
  3/24/2002   1   Institute of Living accuses the Church of exploiting psychiatric records to keep sexually abusive priests in the job; says Bishop Egan deceived them.  
Diocese Reviews Clergy Files on Sex Abuse Cases Stamford
Advocate
3/15/2002 A1 Bishop Lori reviewing personnel files of all members of the clergy in Diocese to determine if past allegations were handled properly. Bishop to create advisory board
  Lori Works to Rebuild Diocesan Credibility   Connecticut Post   3/17/2002   A1   Bishop plans to step up enforcement of the Diocese's sexual-misconduct policy. Review of priests and deacons, lawsuit settlement filed by 26 people.  
Egan Protected Abusive Priests Hartford
Courant
3/17/2002 1 The 7-page treatise that started it all. Specific focus on Pcolka, Carr, and Brett
  Connecticut Report Revisits Egan's Role in Settling Abuse Cases   New York Times   3/18/2002   B1   Times' report on Courant 7-page treatise story  
Egan Mum on Allegations New York Daily News 3/18/2002 3 News' report on Courant 7-page treatise story
  Church Silence Now Deafening   New York Daily News   3/18/2002   4   Pete Hamill Column: rehashing Courant  
Egan Reacts with Silence Hartford
Courant
3/18/2002 1 Courant is mystified that Cardinal Egan has no response to their story.
  Parish Priests Address Sex Abuse Scandal   Stamford
Advocate
  3/18/2002   A1   Court documents reveal former Bishop Egan and Bishop Curtis allowed several priests facing allegations to continue to work in Diocese. Statement from Fr. Malloy. Quotes from diocesan priests  
For a Second Day, Egan Keeps Silent on an Issue Railing the Church New York Times 3/19/2002 B1 Upset Cardinal Egan still hasn't commented on the Courant article
  State to Ask Diocese for Files but Request Limited to Sex Abuse Cases in Past 5 Years   Hartford Courant   3/19/2002   1   State's Attorney asked Diocese to open priest files that fall within the 5-year deadline for persecution  
Priest Cases May Change Law Danbury News-Times 3/20/2002 1 Local Danbury reaction to the Courant story
  Egan Calls Abuse "Abomination"   New York Daily News   3/20/2002   1   Cardinal Egan defends handling of casts but views to report future allegations to the authorities  
Church Responds to Sex Scandal Stamford
Advocate
3/20/2002 1 Past clouds Bishop Lori's 1st Anniversary; press conference at St. Augustine's. Cardinal Egan breaks silence
  "I Want to do This Right"   Connecticut Post   3/20/2002   1   Past clouds Lori's 1st Anniversary; press conference at St. Augustine's. Cardinal Egan breaks silence  
Egan Breaks Silence Hartford
Courant
3/20/2002 1 Past clouds Lori's 1st Anniversary; press conference at St. Augustine's. Cardinal Egan breaks silence
  Egan Defends His Handling of Abuse Cases   New York Times   3/20/2002   B3   Past clouds Lori's 1st Anniversary; press conference at St. Augustine's. Cardinal Egan breaks silence  
Cardinal Sin: Egan Breaks Silence on Church Crisis New York Post 3/20/2002 1 Cardinal Egan defends handling of cases but vows to report future allegations to authorities
  Editorial: Child Abuses Must be Reprinted    Hartford
Courant
  3/21/2002   10   "The Church hierarchy's tendency to hide, cover up, and transfer priests instead of reporting them to the police - must no longer be tolerated"  
Priests Treated at Institute New Haven Register 3/26/2002 5 Managing, not curing, pedophilia was aim if Institute of Living. AP story
  Hartford Institute Treats Priest's "Disorder of Desire"   Connecticut Post   3/26/2002   2   Managing, not curing, pedophilia was aim if Institute of Living. AP story  
Can the Church Be Saved? Time Magazine 4/1/2002 29 National story includes Cardinal Egan, Bridgeport and Courant article
  Joseph Pisani Column: Questions of Bias in Reporting on Church   Stamford
Advocate
  4/19/2002   18   Pro-media, anti-Church  
Priests as 'John Doe' Hartford
Courant
4/23/2002 1 Seven clerics, aided by Church, shielded their files in 2001 settlement
  Papers Argue for Access to Sealed Misconduct Files   Hartford
Courant
  4/25/2002   1   Judge McWeeny rules in favor of Courant and New York Times  
Newspapers Move to Unveil Documents on Abuse Lawsuits New York Times 4/25/2002 B5 Judge McWeeny rules in favor of Courant and New York Times
  Church Policy Disturbs Victims   Connecticut Post   4/29/2002   1   Victims don't like outcome of Vatican summit with Pope John Paul II, feel no need for misconduct review board  
Activitists Identify Accused Priests Connecticut Post 11/13/2002 A1 Survivors First website. Thumbnails of all accusations
  Speaking Out   Fairfield County Catholic   4/1/2002   1   Listing of articles on sexual misconduct issues with page numbers  
Sexual Misconduct Policy of the Diocese Fairfield County Catholic 4/1/2002 2 Question & Answer summarizing the main points of the diocesan misconduct policy. Defines sexual misconduct and outlines reporting procedures.
  The Other Side of the Coin   Fairfield County Catholic   4/1/2002   5   Column by Dee Maggiori reminding readers of the many loyal, devout, hard-working priests who have been hurt and bewildered by the behavior of pedophile priests  
Court Upholds Law; Rules For the Diocese Fairfield County Catholic July/August 2003 3 Connecticut State Appellate Court concludes that allowing newspapers to publish documents sealed by a court would "set a dangerous precedent for overturning other closed cases.
  Diocese Challenges Connecticut Supreme Court Decision   Fairfield County Catholic   June/July 2009   7   Q&A format highlights main points against the Court's ruling in favor of newspapers: protection under law; judicial fairness; lateness of petition; response of Diocese  
Diocese to Seek Review  by U.S. Supreme Court Fairfield County Catholic 8/1/2009 11 Privacy rights of all citizens and First Amendment principles are main reasons the Diocese intends to petition U.S. Supreme Court

 

Charles Carr

Ordained 1980.
Permanently removed from ministry 2002.

Carr was included in the 2001 settlement with victims of sexual abuse.

Headline Publication Date of Publication Page Summary
  Priest Admits to Psych Sessions   Connecticut Post   12/14/1999   A1   Admits to two counseling sessions because of molestation allegations  
Trust Rebuilt, Prayer by Prayer Hartford
Courant
4/20/2002 1 Accusations against former parish priests stun St. Mary's, Bethel, but faith remains
  A Complete Loss of Faith in Egan   Hartford
Courant
  4/21/2002   1   Mother of Carr, Victoria, tells of misplaced trust - St. Mary's in Bethel  
Court Allows Sex Claims Connecticut Post 1/29/2000 A1 Judge McWeeny allows introduction of claims against 7 other priests
  Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around"   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       Our Lady of Fatima complaints from early 80's.  
Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around" Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Carr's modus operandi detailed.
  Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around"   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       "Inaction" reported  
Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around" Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Exchanges from Carr's deposition
  Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around"   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       Carr to Immaculate High School '84  
Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around" Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Msgr. Cusack consulted prior to Carr's hasty transfer
  Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around"   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       Carr sent for counseling  
Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around" Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Transferred to St. Thomas Apostle, Norwalk
  Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around"   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       Abuse of Fleetwood (at St. Thomas Apostle)  
Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around" Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Carr at All Saints in Norwalk
  Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around"   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       Collection of unpaid tuition at Immaculate High School from one of Carr's victim's family  
Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around" Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Lawsuit - 1993, Carr on leave of absence
  Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around"   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       Carr reinstated  
Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around" Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Carr laicized by Rome at Bishop Lori's request
  Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around"   Hartford Courant       Sidebar   "The Carr File" - Complete chronology of Carr's transfers, allegations, etc  
Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around" Hartford Courant Sidebar NB: Carr reinstated by Bishop Egan in 1990 after counseling and returns to Central Catholic.
  Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around"   Hartford Courant       Sidebar   Bishop Egan appointed Carr P.V. at St. Thomas, St. Philip, St. Andrew, - even knowing about allegations.  
Priests Shielded "Though the Diocese Kept Giving Carr New Assignments, Allegations of Sexual Improprities Kept Following Him Around" Hartford Courant Sidebar Suits settled by Diocese in 2001


 

Philip Coleman

Ordained 1959.
Permanently removed from ministry 1995.

Coleman was included in the 2001 settlement with victims of sexual abuse.

Headline Publication Date of Publication Page Summary
  Priest Accused of Sex Assault says he "Not Conscience"   Connecticut Post   6/24/1999   A2   Asleep at all times - did nothing wrong  
"He was Sleeping is not a Defense" Connecticut Post 7/3/1999 A12 Letter to Editor - Taking Diocese to Task
  Priest Owned Houses with Accusers Mom   Connecticut Post   7/24/1999   A1     Summary - of house purchased with Mother of abuse victim  
Judge Rips Sleeping Priests Story Connecticut Post 10/16/1999 A2 Court denies attempt to dismiss suit
  Priest Sex Case Raises Doubts   Connecticut Post   4/14/2002   1   Details surface about Bishop Egan's handling of Coleman - documents obtained by Post  
Accused Priest Allowed to Fill Bridgeport Post Stamford Advocate 4/15/2002 1 AP story on Coleman - rehash of Post story of abuse


 

Martin Federici

Ordained 1966.
Removed from ministry 1996.
Laicized 2003.

Federici was included in the 2001 settlement with victims of sexual abuse.

Headline Publication Date of Publication Page Summary
  Diocese to Settle Sex Suit   Connecticut Post    5/25/1999   A1   Settlement forthcoming for case  
Diocese Blocks Disclosures Connecticut Post  5/11/2002 A1 Recounting of abuse record and career
  Documents Show Priest was Transferred After Abuse Reports   Connecticut Post    5/12/2002   A8   Federici transferred by Bishop Curtis despite several accusations of abuse.  
Bridgeport Diocese Hit with More Sexual Abuse Claims Hartford Courant 10/17/2002 Online AP story - 30 new claims of abuse of 10 inactive priests
  More Priests Abuse Claims   New Haven Register   10/18/2002   A1   AP story - 30 new claims of abuse of 10 inactive priests  
Priests Quits in Sex Abuse Case Connecticut Post  5/28/2003 online AP story - laicization of Federici
  Accused Clergyman Leaves Priesthood   Stamford Advocate   5/29/2003   A5   AP story - laicization of Federici  
Priest Must Not Be Trusted Connecticut Post 6/7/2003 A4 Letter to the editor


 

Raymond Pcolka

Ordained 1965.
Removed from ministry 1993.
Laicized 2004.

Pcolka was included in the 2001 settlement with victims of sexual abuse.

Headline Publication Date of Publication Page Summary
  Court orders suspended priest taken into custody   Greenwich Time   1/21/1991   A5   Arrested  
Priest Named in Second Assault Suit Hartford
Courant
1/9/1993 5 Pcolka, James Krug, Sheron See, Brian Freibitt
  Women Allege Sexual Relations with Archbishop   Associated Press   3/9/1993       New Mexico story - Pcolka mentioned - he has been suspended  
Bridgeport Catholic Diocese Revoke's Priest's Authority Hartford
Courant
3/10/1993 9 Pcolka now out of ministry
  Diocese Acknowledges Records in Sex Abuse   Hartford
Courant
  10/6/1994   9   AP story - Superior Court - diocese says these are complaints kept in priests' files  
Diocese Wants Data Withheld in Sex Case Danbury News Times 10/7/1994 Judge Levin hears arguments to keep files under wraps
  Priest Sex Abuse Records "Secret"   Connecticut Post    10/7/1994   1   Judge Levin hears arguments to keep files under wraps  
Testimony: Archive Lists Abuse Complaints Against Priests Stamford Advocate 10/7/1994 3 Judge Levin hears arguments to keep files under wraps
  Battle Over Church Records Continues   Danbury News Times   10/19/1994   4   Judge Levin hears arguments to keep files under wraps  
No File Was Kept on Accused Priest New Haven Register 10/19/1994 1 Judge Levin hears arguments to keep files under wraps
  Diocese Files at Stake in Child Sex Abuse Case   New Jersey Record   11/14/1994       Church archives are private and only accessible to the Bishop. Case is going to trial  
Priest's File Might go to 15 in Suit Connecticut Post  11/17/1994 1 Judge Levin considers giving Pcolka file to victims
  Court Closes Priests Files   Connecticut Post    12/9/1994   1   Superior Court blocks lawyers - gag order and limited access to Polka's files  
Court Denies Access to Records of Diocesan Priests Danbury News Times 12/10/1994 1 Superior Court blocks lawyers - gag order and limited access to Polka's files
  Judge Limits Infractions in Ex-Priests' Abuse Trial   Stamford Advocate   12/10/1994   3   Superior Court blocks lawyers - gag order and limited access to Polka's files  
Accused Priest Gives Statements Greenwich Times 1/18/1995 3 Pcolka's sworn statements to the court. RE: 15 children he abused
  Priest Accused of Assults Appears For Deposition   Hartford
Courant
  1/18/1995       Pcolka gives a deposition  
Deputy Sheriffs Hunt for No Show priests Connecticut Post  1/20/1999 A1 Failed to answer subpoena, authorities looking for him
  Hunted Priest Said to had Led quiet life in Southbury   Connecticut Post    1/21/1999   A2   Interview: Reaction of neighbors of his condo complex in Southbury  
Closed Door Court Session for Priest in Sex Abuse Case Connecticut Post  3/23/1999 A2 Questioned in a closed door session of Superior Court
  Deposition finished in Priest Sex Abuse Case   Greenwich Time   4/24/1999   A1   Questioned in a closed door session of Superior Court  
Former Priest Accused of Abuse Completes Trial Deposition Stamford Advocate 4/24/1999 A10 Questioned in a closed door session of Superior Court
  Diocese: Priest Sex Abuse Cases are "Tabloid Law"   Greenwich Times   5/10/1999   A1   Diocese implies false and distorted arguments for people seeking $  
Allogations Continue Against Priests Stamford Advocate 5/10/1999 A9 Quotes from Attorneys and updates on continuing allegations
  No Comfort in Words for Victims of Abuse   New York Times   3/14/2001   B5   Op-Ed piece  
"No Comfort in Words for Victims of Abuse" New York Times 3/14/2001 Paul Doyle and Fr. Pcolka - St. James, Stratford
  Secrecy Over Abusive Priests Comes Back to Haunt Church   New York Times   3/12/2002   Online   Ms. See and Mr. Freibott not dissuaded from filing law suit against Fr. Pcolka  
Egan Protected Abusive Priests Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 A1 1983: 18 yr old woman complains to Msgr Cusack of molestation by Pcolka 11 years earlier. Pcolka devices; Cusack does not notify authorities
  Egan Protected Abusive Priests   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       Pcolka twice sent to the institute of living  
Egan Protected Abusive Priests Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 1976: complaints from Holy Name, Stratford. No action taken
  Egan Protected Abusive Priests   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       1992: complaints from Krug. Egan grants leave of absence  
Egan Protected Abusive Priests Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Bishop Egan asked if aware that at least 12 people had complained of sexual abuse by Pcolka: claims not to have been.
  Egan Protected Abusive Priests   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       2 years later, Diocese settles lawsuits  
Trust Rebuilt, Prayer by Prayer Hartford
Courant
4/20/2002 1 Accusations against former parish priests stun St. Mary's Bethel, but faith remains
  Bridgeport Diocese Hit with More Sexual Abuse Claims   Hartford
Courant
  10/17/2002   Online   AP story - 30 new claims of abuse of 10 inactive priests  
More Priests Abuse Claims New Haven Register 10/18/2002 A1 AP story - 30 new claims of abuse of 10 inactive priests
  More Priests Abuse Claims   Stamford Advocate   10/18/2002       AP story - 30 new claims of abuse of 10 inactive priests  
More Priests Abuse Claims Connecticut Post  10/18/2002 AP story - 30 new claims of abuse of 10 inactive priests
  Lori Moving to Oust Priest in Abuse Case   Connecticut Post    10/20/2002   A3   Mentions Pcolka- story on Stanley Bonaszek  
Diocesan Appeal Begins Friday Connecticut Post  1/6/2003 A1 Judge McWeeny  - Diocese asks appellate court to block release of sealed files.  Pcolka mentioned


 

Laurence Brett

Ordained 1962.
Removed from ministry and laicized.
Present whereabouts unknown

Brett was not included in the 2001 settlement but the Diocese has settled with victims of sexual abuse by Brett.

Headline Publication Date of Publication Page Summary
  Documents Show Church Knew of Porter's Problems   Associated Press   1/7/1993       Brett, James Porter, and New Mexico  
Court Rejects Verdict of Case Against Diocese Stamford Advocate 11/12/1999 A1 Court throws out lawsuit by Wisconsin man with claim of abuse
  Diocese Wins New Trial     Connecticut Post   11/12/1999   A1   Court throws out lawsuit by Wisconsin man with claim of abuse  
Diocese Wins New Trial in Sex Abuse Case Norwalk Hour 11/13/1999 A4 Court throws out lawsuit by Wisconsin man with claim of abuse
  Diocese Appeals Ruling on Liability on Abuse   Connecticut Post   11/30/1999   A4   Diocese asks for reconsideration on Churches responsibility on abuse matters  
Diocese Settles Sex Suit Connecticut Post 4/4/2000 A1 Settlement on Brett - details of allegations
  Egan Still Must Testify on Priests - Sex Suits   Connecticut Post   5/12/2000   A16   Tremont & Shelton pressure Bishop Egan to testify.  
Egan Protected Abusive Priests Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 1 Details Bishop Egan's deposition regarding his handling of Brett
  Egan Protected Abusive Priests   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002   A11-12   Gives a summary of Brett's history and how Curtis and Egan handled him  
Church Investigated an Accuser Hartford
Courant
3/22/2002 1 Accusations vs Brett led to  scrutiny  of alleged victims in New Mexico. Story based on sealed documents.
  Disclosure Bill for Sex Abuse Raises Worries   Connecticut Post   5/4/2002   A1   Bishop Lori reviewing new complaints within Diocese - Whereabouts of Brett unknown  
Egan supported Priest Accused of Sexual Abuse Greenwich Time 5/11/2002 A1 Bishop Egan protected, transferred Brett despite knowledge of abuse
  Egan's Testimony Surfaces Again   Connecticut Post   5/12/2002   A4   Bishop Egan's meeting with Brett  
More Trouble in the Church The Day.Com 5/14/2002 Online Bishop Egan's handling of Brett case
  Aide Defends Egan's Actions in Priest Case   New York Times   5/15/2002   Online   New York Archdiocese defends Egan's handling of Brett case in Bridgeport  
Abusive Priests Found on Caribbean Island Stamford Advocate 8/29/2002 Online Frs. Howell and Devore chastised for not revealing whereabouts of Brett
  Accused Priests Discovered on Caribbean Island   Hartford
Courant
  8/29/2002   Online   Frs. Howell and Devore chastised for not revealing whereabouts of Brett  
Priest's Admonished silence about Brett Norwalk Hour 8/29/2002 Online Frs. Howell and Devore chastised for not revealing whereabouts of Brett
  Priest's Role Questioned by Diocese   Connecticut Post   8/30/2002   A7   Frs. Howell and Devore chastised for not revealing whereabouts of Brett  
Bridgeport Diocese Disciplined for Helping Fugitive Catholic World News 9/1/2002 Frs. Howell and Devore chastised for not revealing whereabouts of Brett
  Two Bridgeport Priests Reproved for Protecting Abused Priests   New York Times   9/1/2002   Online   Frs. Howell and Devore chastised for not revealing whereabouts of Brett  
Reaction Mixed to Priests Removal Stamford Advocate 9/3/2002 Online
  Pastors do Penance for Silence   Hartford
Courant
  9/3/2002       Frs. Howell and Devore chastised for not revealing whereabouts of Brett  
Priest Accused of Molestation Still on the Lam Stamford Advocate 4/14/2002 1 Martinelli fears Brett, whereabouts unknown, still out there abusing
  Bridgeport Diocese Quietly Settled 2 Sex Abuse Complaints   Stamford Advocate   4/24/2002   1   Brett & Calvert Hall, Maryland  
Bridgeport Diocese Quietly Settled Lawsuits Hartford
Courant
4/24/2002 1 Brett & Calvert Hall, Maryland
  A Predator Blessed with Charm   Hartford Courant   9/15/2002       Details of victimization  
A Predator Blessed with Charm Greenwich Time 9/15/2002 Details of victimization
  A Predator Blessed with Charm   Stamford Advocate   9/15/2002       Details of victimization  
Priests Say They are Sorry  Stamford Advocate 10/21/2002 A1 Frs. Howell and Devore apologizing for not speaking up of Brett's whereabouts
  Lori Reviews Fixes to Sex Abuse Policy   Stamford Advocate   11/3/2002   A3   Dallas Charter; mentions Brett  
Church Abuse Scandal Hits Home Stamford Advocate 12/29/2002 A4 Year in Review - capstone piece on clergy abuse in 2002 - Brett mentioned
  Priest Sited in Cover-up - Reassigned   Connecticut Post   5/29/2003   A11   Reassignment of Fr. Devore to Weston  

Cardinal Edward M. Egan

Bishop of the Diocese of Bridgeport, 1988-2000.
Archbishop of New York, 2000-2009.
Presently retired.

Headline Publication Date of Publication Page Summary
  The Archbishop's Tale   The Village Voice   5/31/2000   Online   Archbp. Egan's Bpt record offers little hope to progressives - handling of sex abuse cases  
Egan Foes work to Settle Sex Suits Against Diocese Connecticut Post 6/6/2000 A1 Archbishop Egan worked to settle cases as leaves for NY
  Egan is Leaving "Unfinished Work on Abuse" Victims say   New York Times   6/16/2000   B1   General case on abuse nationally - cases follow him to NY  
Ruling Make Clear Way for Egan Testimony Connecticut Post  9/28/2000 A2 Appellate Court rules that accused priests can block access to personal files
  Court Lets Priests Intervene in Abuse Cases   Stamford Advocate   9/28/2000   A9   Appellate Court rules that accused priests can block access to personal files  
Egan Protected Abusive Priests Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Bishop Egan allowed abusive priests to continue in ministry after receiving multiple allegations
  Egan Protected Abusive Priests   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       Cardinal Egan doubts (dismisses) allegations even when they follow a pattern  
Egan Protected Abusive Priests Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Courant had many of sealed documents on which article based, including Bishop Egan's deposition
  Egan Protected Abusive Priests   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       Inherited scandal from Bishop Curtis  
Egan Protected Abusive Priests Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Bishop Egan reinstated Carr
  Egan Protected Abusive Priests   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       Bishop Egan won't let victims know about the allegations of other victims re same priest  
Egan Protected Abusive Priests Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 "Legalistic evasion and semantic parsing"
  Egan Protected Abusive Priests   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       Bishop E gan defends 1964 "hepatitis" memo (Brett)  
Egan Protected Abusive Priests Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Bishop Egan found Brett "impressive" 
  Egan Protected Abusive Priests   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002       Sidebar: allowed Brett to remain a priest on the basis of psychiatric recommendation  
Egan Protected Abusive Priests Hartford Courant 3/17/2002 Sidebar Cardinal Egan disputes scope of abuse - 'relatively small'
  Egan Protected Abusive Priests   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002   Sidebar   Cardinal Egan disputes 18 year old victim of Brett be called a 'young boy'  
Church Responds to Sex Scandal Stamford Advocate 3/20/2002 A1 Cardinal Egan calls abuse abomination and mention is made of his time in Bpt
  In Letter, Egan Defends Role in Bridgeport   Stamford Advocate   3/24/2002   1   AP stay in new policy in New York, said he did no wrong in Bridgeport  
Egan Defends Handling of Abuse Claims Hartford
Courant
3/24/2002 1 AP stay in new policy in New York, said he did no wrong in Bridgeport
  Sex Abuse Handling Defended by Egan   Connecticut
Post
  3/24/2002   1   AP stay in new policy in New York, said he did no wrong in Bridgeport  
Sexual Abuse of Children: "Abomination" Fairfield County Catholic 4/1/2002 4 Cardinal Egan's letter to the Archdiocese of New York. The policy of the Archdiocese requires personnel to report charges of sexual abuse, and encourages that abuse suspicions be reported to civil authorities.
  Most Polled Think Bishops in Sex Scandal Should Resign   Stamford Advocate   4/12/2002   7   Quinnipiac polling 31% of CT Catholics say Cardinal Egan should resign due to Bridgeport cases mishandling  
Editorial: "Cardinal Egan Must Resign" Connecticut Post 4/14/2002 B1 Transformation and healing can only begin by removing Cardinal Egan
  Page of Letters on Call for Egan's Resignation   Connecticut Post   4/17/2002   14   2 pro Cardinal Egan; 1 against  
Cardinal Egan Faint Apology New York Post 4/20/2002 1 "Egan says he's sorry - sort of." Admits "may have made" mistakes with Peru priests while in Bridgeport
  Egan Offers Apology   Stamford Advocate   4/21/2002   7   Admits in letter he may have made mistakes in Bpt, apologizes "in hindsight"  
Hindsight' Apology From Egan Connecticut Post 4/21/2002 1 Admits in letter he may have made mistakes in Bpt, apologizes "in hindsight"
  Egan Says He May Have Mishandled Sex Abuse Cases   New York Times   4/21/2002   31   Admits in letter he may have made mistakes in Bpt, apologizes "in hindsight"  
"I am deeply sorry" - But Egan Doesn't Admit Mistakes New Haven Register 4/21/2002 1 Admits in letter he may have made mistakes in Bpt, apologizes "in hindsight"
  Cardinal's Rules   New York Times   5/14/2002   Online   Cardinal Egan's fast rise tarnished by sex abuse handling  
  Open the Pedophilia Files   Hartford
Courant
  5/23/2002   A14   Editorial of Judge McWeeny handling of the Bpt cases and Cardinals actions in Bpt  
Cardinal Egan Defends Record Abuse Cases New York Times 8/16/2002 Defending policy while he was Bishop of Bridgeport
  Egan: I responded Properly to Abuse   Connecticut Post   8/17/2009   A6   Interview about NYT article of Aug 16, 2002, defending policies  


 

Bishop William E. Lori

Bishop of the Diocese of Bridgeport, 2001-present.

The March 8, 2001, settlement with victims was concluded before Bishop Lori's installation as Bishop of Bridgeport.

Headline Publication Date of Publication Page Summary
  A Candid Response After Priest's Arrest   Stamford Advocate   6/1/2001   A16   Editorial: Bishop Lori's handling of Castaldo matter straightforward, reassuring , and a welcome change  
Diocese, Bishop Handle Problems More Effectively Connecticut Post 6/4/2001 A10 Editorial: Bishop Lori to be commended for handling sex abuse issue more openly and decisively than ever before.
  Bishop's response "breath of fresh air!"   Connecticut Post   6/13/2001   A8   Letter-to-the-Editor: Bishop's "quick and powerful response" to Castaldo matter makes clear this is a new era for the Diocese of Bridgeport  
Bishop Names New Pastor at Holy Name of Jesus Stamford Advocate 2/15/2002 A9 New pastors named to parishes, some to succeed priests removed due to sex abuse allegations
  Bronkiewicz among three replacement priests named by Lori   Connecticut Post   2/15/2002   A2   New pastors named to parishes, some to succeed priests removed due to sex abuse allegations  
Lori Works to Rebuild Diocesan Credibility Connecticut Post 3/17/2002 A1 Bishop Lori acts quickly to drop or reform Egan-era policies; several abusive priests briefly profiled
  The Situation Today   Hartford Courant   3/17/2002   A12   Short account of how Bishop Lori stepped up the policies and investigations  
Parish Priests Address Sex Abuse Scandal Stamford Advocate 3/18/2002 A1 Scandal addressed at parishes, Bishop Lori says priests will no longer be shuffled around and pledges protection of children
  Church responds to sex scandal    Stamford Advocate   3/20/2002   A1   Bishop Lori's 1st Anniversary Press Conference commitment to transparency  
Good Friday Came Early Fairfield County Catholic 4/1/2002 3 Bishop Lori column on the sexual abuse scandal. He re-commits to the sexual misconduct policy established by Cardinal Egan, and encouraged priests to continued holiness
  Bridgeport Diocese List with More Sexual Abuse Claims   Hartford
Courant
  10/17/2002   Online   Bishop Lori named to a national panel and is committed to swift action; complaints about Gorecki, Grady, Bietighofer, Donovan, Federici, Pcolka, Stubbs, DeShan  
More Priest Abuse Claimed New Haven Register 10/18/2002 A1 Bishop Lori named to a national panel and is committed to swift action; complaints about Gorecki, Grady, Bietighofer, Donovan, Federici, Pcolka, Stubbs, DeShan
  Diocese Hit With 30 New Sex-Abuse Claims   Stamford Advocate   10/18/2002   A3   Bishop Lori named to a national panel and is committed to swift action; complaints about Gorecki, Grady, Bietighofer, Donovan, Federici, Pcolka, Stubbs, DeShan  
30? File New Sex Assault Claims Connecticut Post 10/18/2002 A1 Bishop Lori named to a national panel and is committed to swift action; complaints about Gorecki, Grady, Bietighofer, Donovan, Federici, Pcolka, Stubbs, DeShan
  Lori Moving to Oust Priest in Abuse Case   Connecticut Post   10/20/2002   A3   Bishop Lori undertakes laicization process for Pcolka, Bonaszek name surfaces  
Priests Say They Are Sorry Stamford Advocate 10/21/2002 A1 Bishop "Gravely Disappointed" at Devore and Howell failing to disclose Brett's whereabouts
  Lori Abuse Policy Will Stay in Effect   Connecticut Post   10/22/2002   A18   Editorial: Bishop Lori "continues to take the proper course" on sex abuses.   
Lori Reviews Fixes to Sex Abuse Policy Stamford Advocate 11/3/2002 A3 Press conference at St. Leo's explaining new guidelines VOTF Complaints
  Activists Identify Accused Priests   Connecticut Post   11/13/2002   A1   Survivors first website, Bishop Lori remains committed to removing offenders, due process; 19 brief profiles  
Bishop "Law and Order" Lori Takes the Paint Hartford
Courant
11/13/2002 Online Bishop Lori a bright and articulate spokesman for Dallas norms
  Bishops OK Revised Sex Abuse Policy   Stamford Advocate   11/14/2002   A1   Approval of Dallas Charter at USCCB November meeting Bishop Lori: "No priest who has ever abused a child can remain in ministry"  
U.S. Bishops Ratify Policy on Sex Abuse  Connecticut Post 11/14/2002 A1 Approval of Dallas Charter at USCCB November meeting Bishop Lori: "No priest who has ever abused a child can remain in ministry"
  Church's New Policy on Abuse Gets Mixed Reaction   Stamford Advocate   11/15/2002   A1   Area Catholics pleased with Dallas; some concerns about wrongly accused priests; Bridgeport reassures  
  Diocese Policy Questions Raised in Woman's Claims of Sex Abuse   Connecticut Post   11/24/2002   A1   Questions raised about Bishop Lori's sexual abuse policy; says Bishop never met with her  


 

Father Joseph Malloy

Ordained 1970.
Included in the 2001 settlement; exonerated of a single claim against him.
Presently a priest in good standing and in active ministry.

Headline Publication Date of Publication Page Summary
  Diocese Announces the Resolution of Lawsuits   Fairfield County Catholic   Mar/Apr 2001   4   Msgr Bronkiewicz, administrator and chancellor of the Diocese, announced the successful conclusion of the mediation process. Page includes diocesan support for Father Joseph Malloy and a statement by Msgr. Bronkiewicz  
Priest Denies Sex Abuse Charges Connecticut Post 3/11/2002 A1 Malloy Denies Allegations
  Parish Priests Address Sex Abuse Scandal   Stamford Advocate   3/18/2002   A1   Priests Address allegations at weekend masses and Fr. Malloy denies wrongdoing  
Joe Pisani column: "Innocence vs Guilt in Church Sex Scandal Greenwich Time 3/29/2002 20 "Was an innocent man falsely accused? We have no way of knowing"
  Letters to the Editor   Greenwich Time   3/29/2002   20   Two Letters: one supportive, the other not  
Like a Ton of Bricks: Stamford Priest Hit Hard by Sex Abuse Scandal Stamford Advocate 3/24/2002 1 Fr. Malloy's new parish learns about the 2001 settlement for first time.
  Letter to the Editor: "Accused Priest"   Stamford Advocate   4/5/2002   18   Positive Father Malloy Letter  

 

For More Information

Our goal is to keep you informed by providing timely and reliable information
about important matters impacting our Diocese. More complete information
and future updates will be posted online; please check often.

We appreciate your continued support of our efforts and ask that you contact us
should you have any questions, comments or concerns.
Please e-mail contactus@diobpt.org.

Thank you.

 

Copyright 2010 • The Roman Catholic Diocese of Bridgeport • All Rights Reserved
Website Design by Magtype Computer Resources